Fishtail Inn Bar/Grill

Nestled in the heart of Hilbert, WI, Fishtail Inn Bar/Grill is a cozy and inviting spot known for its welcoming atmosphere and delicious offerings. Located at W5636 Cty Rd Ee, this family-friendly eatery has become a local favorite for those seeking high-quality food and friendly service in a relaxed setting. Whether you're stopping by for a casual dinner or celebrating a special occasion, Fishtail Inn Bar/Grill promises a memorable dining experience that’s hard to beat.

A Delicious Selection of Comfort Food

The menu at Fishtail Inn Bar/Grill features a variety of mouthwatering dishes, with an emphasis on freshly prepared meals that highlight the flavors of the region. While specific menu items can vary, some of the standout offerings include expertly prepared fish dishes, tender steaks, and seafood specialties. The establishment is particularly praised for its fish, which is often the dish of choice for many patrons. The rich flavors and expertly seasoned dishes, like the tenderloin and shrimp specials, are a highlight. In addition, the restaurant’s signature cold strawberry soup has garnered attention for being both unexpected and delightful, offering a unique twist for those looking to try something new.

While the food is certainly a key attraction, it’s the overall experience that keeps guests coming back. The staff at Fishtail Inn Bar/Grill are known for their warm hospitality, making diners feel right at home, whether it's their first visit or a frequent stop.

The Unpretentious Atmosphere and Attentive Service

At Fishtail Inn Bar/Grill, the focus is on creating a laid-back, unpretentious environment where guests can unwind and enjoy a meal in peace. The staff is frequently mentioned in reviews for their friendliness and attentive service. One customer, Heather L., shared her appreciation for the restaurant’s welcoming atmosphere, saying, "Great food and drink and friendly staff!" She especially loved the fish dishes, which were fresh and flavorful, creating a memorable experience for her group. This type of personal service seems to be a hallmark of the restaurant, with many guests commenting on how the team makes them feel comfortable and cared for throughout their visit.

A Perfect Spot for Special Occasions and Casual Dining

Whether you're in the mood for a quick dinner or looking to celebrate a special event, Fishtail Inn Bar/Grill offers a versatile setting that caters to a variety of dining needs. As described by C.C., another regular customer, “The restaurant may be unpretentious but the food is first class.” The combination of delicious meals and a welcoming atmosphere makes it a fantastic choice for both locals and visitors. The tenderloin, described as “melt in your mouth,” and the fresh seafood are among the dishes that consistently draw praise.

Moreover, the bar area offers a range of drinks to pair perfectly with your meal, making it an ideal spot for both casual diners and those looking to unwind with a drink in hand.

Real Reviews from Satisfied Guests

The rave reviews speak volumes about the consistent quality of both the food and service. Guests such as Heather L. and C.C. have left glowing feedback, praising the food, the service, and the overall experience at Fishtail Inn Bar/Grill. Their feedback reflects the restaurant’s commitment to providing top-notch dining in a friendly and approachable setting. For anyone looking to enjoy a delicious meal in a comfortable, unpretentious environment, Fishtail Inn Bar/Grill has earned its place as a beloved local gem.

With its unique blend of quality food, great service, and a relaxed atmosphere, Fishtail Inn Bar/Grill stands as a must-try destination in Hilbert. Whether you're indulging in the fish, savoring a steak, or enjoying one of their delightful specialties, you're sure to leave with a smile on your face and a satisfied stomach.